Suggestions

Discord suggestion system with Cakey Bot - vote on suggestions, and accept/deny/duplicate/review/pause decisions with reasons. Setup guide.

Last updated Nov 4, 2026

Overview

Suggestions let your members propose ideas and vote on them with a simple upvote/downvote embed. Staff can then accept, deny, mark as a duplicate, put a suggestion under review, or pause it - each decision updates the suggestion's embed with a colored status and an optional reason, and is recorded so it shows up in the dashboard's decision history.

A Suggestion Channel must be configured before members can create suggestions - see Configuring Suggestions below.

Configuring Suggestions

  1. Login to our web dashboard.
  2. Go to the "Suggestions" page and set the Suggestion Channel where new suggestions will be posted. This is required - /suggestion create won't work until it's set.
  3. On that same page, optionally set the Suggestion Approved Channel / Suggestion Denied Channel to forward a copy of accepted/denied suggestions there as well. This happens whether the decision is made with the buttons or with /suggestion accept and /suggestion deny.
  4. Optionally set a Suggestion Ping Role, which is pinged whenever a new suggestion is posted. The role needs to be mentionable, or the bot needs permission to mention any role.
  5. Optionally turn on Create a thread for each suggestion and choose a Thread after a decision option. See Suggestion Threads below.

The ping role is only mentioned when a suggestion is first posted - deciding on it later (accept/deny/duplicate/review/pause) does not ping it again.

Creating a Suggestion

Once a Suggestion Channel is configured, any member can run /suggestion create to open a form asking for a title and description. Submitting it posts an embed - always in the configured Suggestion Channel, regardless of which channel the command was run in - with upvote/downvote buttons, an Approve/Deny button pair, and a Create Discussion Thread button. The confirmation that your suggestion was posted is only visible to you.

Suggestion Threads

When Create a thread for each suggestion is turned on, Cakey Bot opens a public thread under every new suggestion for discussion. The thread is named after the suggestion's title. The bot needs the Create Public Threads permission in the Suggestion Channel.

Thread after a decision controls what happens to a suggestion's thread once it is decided:

Option Result
Leave it open The thread is left as it is.
Lock and archive it The thread is locked and archived.
Archive it The thread is archived.
Delete it The thread is deleted.

This applies when a suggestion is accepted, denied or marked a duplicate, with either the buttons or the slash commands. Marking a suggestion as under review or paused leaves its thread alone. The bot needs the Manage Threads permission.

If no Suggestion Channel is configured yet, /suggestion create shows an error explaining that an admin needs to set one up first, with a link to this article.

Voting

Members vote using the 👍/👎 buttons on a suggestion embed. Voting the opposite direction swaps your vote; clicking the same button again removes it. Vote counts are shown directly on the buttons.

Deciding on a Suggestion

Members with the Administrator or Manage Server permission can decide on a suggestion two ways:

  • Buttons - Click Approve or Deny directly on the suggestion embed. This updates the embed's color and footer immediately, but doesn't support attaching a reason.
  • Slash commands - /suggestion accept, /suggestion deny, /suggestion duplicate, /suggestion review, or /suggestion pause, each taking the suggestion's message link or ID and an optional reason. These support all five outcomes (including Duplicate, Under Review and Paused, which have no button equivalent) and let you explain the decision.

A suggestion that is under review or paused stays open, so members can keep voting and staff can still approve or deny it with the buttons.

Whichever path is used, the suggestion's embed color updates to match the outcome:

Status Color
Accepted Green
Denied Red
Duplicate Blue
Under Review Yellow
Paused Purple

If a reason was given, it's added to the embed as a Reason field. Deciding on a suggestion again (with either method) replaces its previous decision.

The suggestion's message ID doubles as autocomplete for the slash commands - typing part of a suggestion's title will suggest matching recent suggestions.

Dashboard Decision History

The dashboard's Suggestions page lists every decision made for your server - status, moderator, reason, and when it was decided - and lets you edit a decision after the fact. Editing from the dashboard saves the change and updates the live embed in Discord to match.

Limitations/Restrictions

  • Decisions are keyed to the suggestion's Discord message - if a suggestion's message is manually deleted in Discord, its vote and decision records are automatically cleaned up and it disappears from the dashboard history.
  • The Suggestion Channel setting itself can still be cleared after suggestions already exist. If that happens, the bot loses track of which channel those older suggestions live in - this limits autocomplete, requires a full message link (not a bare ID) for the slash commands, and prevents the dashboard from syncing edits back to Discord, for suggestions created while a different (or no) channel was configured.
  • Only the most recent decision for a suggestion is kept - deciding again overwrites the previous outcome rather than keeping a history of every change.

Related Commands

  • Posts a suggestion for users to vote on

    /suggestion create
  • Accepts a suggestion.

    /suggestion accept <suggestion> [reason]
  • Denies a suggestion.

    /suggestion deny <suggestion> [reason]
  • Marks a suggestion as a duplicate of another one.

    /suggestion duplicate <suggestion> [reason]
  • Marks a suggestion as under review.

    /suggestion review <suggestion> [reason]
  • Marks a suggestion as paused.

    /suggestion pause <suggestion> [reason]